Seen from above, the lakes form the print of a hand — Iroquois legend holds that the Great Spirit pressed his palm into this land to bless it, and the hollows filled with water. Three of those fingers organize this guide. Seneca is the reservoir of the chain, holding roughly half of all the water in the Finger Lakes. Cayuga unwinds more than 95 miles of shoreline, more lakefront than any of its neighbors. Canandaigua keeps water so clean it was voted the best drinking water in New York State in 2013 and 2017, and clear enough to show its bottom thirty feet down. Every hotel below was chosen at the window, not at the front desk.
Canandaigua Lake keeps exactly one luxury resort at its waterfront, and this is it — hand-carved furniture and hardwood flooring in the rooms, and the nine green acres of Kershaw Park stretching along the north end of the lake a three-minute walk away.

Five inns, each more than a century old, share a single village street on the east side of Cayuga Lake — balconies at the 1833 Aurora Inn hang over the water, and Rowland House keeps a two-story boathouse of 1903 on its own stretch of shore.
None of the 15 rooms has a television — the house decided long ago what its guests would watch. From 2.5 hilltop acres, Seneca Lake spreads below the mansion, a short walk above downtown Watkins Glen, and the giant wrap-around porch holds the widest seat on it.
Three of the fingers carry certified stays: Canandaigua Lake at The Lake House on Canandaigua, Cayuga Lake at Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa, and Seneca Lake at Idlwilde Inn. Each one puts the water directly in front of the room — private balconies with 180º panoramic views of Canandaigua Lake at the first, balconies with commanding views of Cayuga Lake at the second, and a wrap-around porch with year-round views of Seneca Lake at the third.
The Lake House on Canandaigua holds the lake's only luxury waterfront position, and the view runs through the whole property: lakeview guestrooms and suites, many with private balconies overlooking the lake, plus lakefront restaurants and a lakeside pool. Even the spa keeps the water in sight — the barrel saunas face the lake.
Ask for a lakefront room in the main building — these come with a spacious private balcony offering 180º panoramic views of Canandaigua Lake, plus hardwood floors and artisanal furnishings. Be specific when booking, because some suites at The Lake House on Canandaigua face the town rather than the water.
Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa, whose flagship Aurora Inn sits in the heart of the village on the shores of Cayuga Lake. Its Premier Lake View rooms are the ones to ask for: in the warmer months, a semi-private balcony with rocking chairs offers commanding views of Cayuga Lake.
The Aurora Inn hangs its balconies directly over the shore, while E.B. Morgan House and Rowland House give guests private swimming areas and lakeside docks on Cayuga Lake. Rowland House is the sunset pick — its classic rooms feature sunset views over Cayuga Lake — and all five houses of Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa share one walkable village street.
Idlwilde Inn, an 1892 Victorian mansion perched on 2.5 hilltop acres overlooking Seneca Lake, a short walk from downtown Watkins Glen. The house was built for the panorama: many rooms offer views of Seneca Lake, and the large wrap-around porch is the widest seat on it.
Room 6, the master suite of Idlwilde Inn — spacious and elegant with two decorative fireplaces, an enclosed porch with windows all around, and a second porch with a spectacular view of Seneca Lake. Book by name, since rooms come with garden or lake views and only some face the water.
Aurora sits on the east shore of Cayuga, so at Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa the dramatic sunset splashes across the sky over the water each dusk — Rowland House rooms frame it directly. At Idlwilde Inn the light works the other way: guests on the front porch watch the sun rise over Seneca Lake.
Autumn — peak foliage in the Finger Lakes historically runs mid-October through early November, with the southern hills near Watkins Glen typically turning first and lakeside towns like Canandaigua running a bit later. In summer, the balconies earn their keep: the Aurora Inn's lake-view balconies at Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa come into their own in the warmer months.
Yes, at all three. The Lake House on Canandaigua sits on the lakefront with lakefront restaurants and a lakeside pool; at Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa, E.B. Morgan House and Rowland House keep lakeside docks and private swimming areas; and from Idlwilde Inn it is a walk down the hill to the marina on Seneca Lake.
A few views a month, chosen by hand. Nothing else.
We use cookies to understand how travellers use the site. Cookies
Please rotate your screen